All apparently works fine. But whether captcha enabled or not, the user cannot log in. I can't create conditions under which login is successful. Every user is blocked from logging in.
If you installed this plugin first time with lot more user previously registered you should make theme verified manually from the user list, please see the screenshot
Otherwise, they will need to get verified before login, when an unverfied user try to login there will an error message showing to get verification mail,
These error message might not work in custom login form until it compatible our plugin,
we have support for WooCommerce, Ultimate Member and Paid membership Pro plugin.
Hope you understand the issue.
Welcome to our forum.
Can you please tell me whether you use default login for or custom?
I will check the plugin and try to fix the issue.